From Graphic Novels to Restaurant Themes: Building a Pop-Up Menu Around a Transmedia IP

Turn fandom into foot traffic: why your pop-up menu must tell a story

Struggling to convert an IP’s fans into paying guests? You’re not alone. Diners want experiences that match the worlds they love, but many pop-ups deliver costumes and décor while leaving the menu as an afterthought. The result: low repeat visits, poor merchandise sales, and wasted licensing opportunities. This guide shows how to build a themed pop-up around a transmedia IP — using The Orangery’s 2025–26 success as a model — so your menu, merchandising and licensing become the revenue engines they should be. For tactical micro-event framing, see Micro-Events to Micro-Markets.

The big idea: transmedia dining in 2026

In late 2025 and early 2026 we saw a clear acceleration of transmedia dining — IP owners partnering with hospitality operators to create immersive meals tied to graphic novels, festivals and live events. The Orangery, the Turin-based transmedia studio behind the hit graphic novel series Traveling to Mars and Sweet Paprika, signed with WME in January 2026, signaling major agency interest in culinary collaborations that amplify IP reach across platforms.

At the same time, event and nightlife investors doubled down on themed experiences. As Marc Cuban recently said about the experience economy:

"It’s time we all got off our asses, left the house and had fun." — Marc Cuban

How The Orangery teaches us to think like an IP partner

The Orangery builds worlds first — graphic novels, character bibles, music, and transmedia tie-ins — then licenses experiences. For restaurateurs that means: design a menu that reads like a chapter of the IP, not an appendixed catering list. There are three immediate takeaways from their trajectory:

• World fidelity matters: Fans notice authenticity. Use character backstories, canonical ingredients and color palettes from the IP.
• Modular storytelling: Make dishes deliverables that can be adapted for different formats (pop-up dinners, festival kiosks, in-store promotions).
• Cross-platform revenue: Combine ticketed dinners with limited-edition merch and digital collectibles to lift ARPU (average revenue per user).

Step-by-step: Building a pop-up menu around a graphic novel IP

1. Start with a story arc — not a recipe list

Map a simple narrative that runs through the meal: arrival, conflict, climax, resolution. For example, a "Martian Landing" multi-course menu (inspired by Traveling to Mars) could follow the crew’s first night on Mars: cold, savory, then bright and sweet for discovery.

2. Translate characters into dishes

Assign one or two signature dishes per major character or location. Make each menu item tell a micro-story in its name and description.

• Use evocative names: "Commander Zev’s Ion-Grilled Octopus" rather than "grilled octopus."
• Include a one-line lore snippet under the dish to reinforce IP context.

3. Design with sensory staging in mind

Think plating, sound, and olfactory cues. Fog machines and citrus spritzes can underscore scenes. Keep operations realistic: if a dish needs a 12-minute sous-vide finish, plan it as a plated-course rather than à la minute street food. For promoter and production gear checklists, see Night Promoter Workflow: Gear That Keeps Pop‑Ups Moving.

4. Prioritize accessibility and allergies

Fans are diverse. Mark vegetarian, vegan, gluten-free and common allergens. Offer clearly labeled swaps that preserve story beats (e.g., "Helene’s Vegan Stardust Sauce — same story, no dairy"). For designing inclusive in-person events and accessibility considerations, consult Designing Inclusive In‑Person Events: Accessibility, Spatial Audio, and Acknowledgment Rituals.

5. Price for experience, not just food cost

Ticketed themed dinners can command a premium. Use tiered pricing: standard entry, VIP (priority seating + signed print), and table experiences (actor interaction, extended tasting). Always publish what's included. If you need projection models or cash-flow templates for tier pricing, see our forecasting & cash-flow toolkit.

Sample full pop-up menu: "A Night in the Orangery — Worlds Collide"

This sample menu interweaves elements of Traveling to Mars and Sweet Paprika. Prices are illustrative for a major market (2026).

Amuse-Bouche — Boarding Pass (Complimentary)

• "Orbit Blossom" — compressed citrus, micro-basil, dehydrated paprika dust (vegan)

Starters

• Commander Zev’s Ion-Grilled Octopus — charred tentacle, smoked paprika aioli, roasted fennel. $18
• Sweet Paprika Flatbread — roasted peppers, spiced tomato confit, torn mozzarella (vegetarian). $14
• Martian Garden Salad — beet spiral, candied citrus, pistachio crumble (vegan, GF). $12

Mains

• Helene’s Red Dune Risotto — charred tomato, saffron foam, basil oil (vegetarian). $24
• Outpost Braised Short Rib — smoked bone jus, paprika mash, pickled shallots. $28
• Traveler’s Seared Barramundi — citrus ferment, sea-salt tuile (GF). $26

Desserts

• Cosmonaut Crème Brûlée — with candied paprika rim. $10
• Spice Market Sundae — paprika caramel, candied orange, salted almond brittle. $9

Drinks & Cocktails

• Martian Mule — infused vodka, smoked paprika syrup, lime. $14
• Sweet Paprika Nightcap — spiced rum, chocolate, roasted pepper bitters. $13
• Non-alc: Nebula Shrub — hibiscus, ginger, lemon (vegan). $7

Menu notes: Include allergy icons, vegetarian/vegan markers, and a QR code linking to the IP lore page and a printable collector menu. Offer a two-course kids menu ($12) with simpler names and smaller portions.

Merchandising: make products that amplify the menu

Merch is where margins expand quickly. Use scarcity and storytelling to create must-have items. For compact, high-impact merchandising ideas see Compact Merch & Promo Ideas.

High-impact SKUs

• Limited-edition enamel pins and numbered prints tied to the event date.
• Recipe zines: a 12-page mini-booklet with 3 signature recipes and illustrated lore ($8–15).
• Branded spice blends: "Sweet Paprika Dust" — packaged in limited runs ($12–20).
• Premium bundles: dinner + signed graphic novel + exclusive spice tin (VIP price).

Merch ops & marketing hacks

• Sell merch at the entrance and at a separate merch station to avoid ticketing friction.
• Use POS analytics to bundle best-sellers with menu items (e.g., buy the Martian Mule, get 10% off the spice tin).
• Offer a postcard or digital collectible (watermarked) for social shares; encourage tagging for a small discount.

Licensing basics for restaurateurs (practical checklist)

Negotiating with an IP owner is simpler when you know what matters. Below are the high-level terms you'll encounter and practical negotiating stances.

• Scope of rights — Limited-time pop-up vs. ongoing residency. Ask for precise start/end dates and territory. For one-off dinners, request a short-term, low-fee pilot license.
• Merch rights — Clarify whether you can sell branded goods. If the owner wants to control merch, propose revenue splits (e.g., 60/40 operator/owner) or minimum guarantees.
• Approval process — IP owners typically require creative approvals. Build a 10–14 day review buffer into your timeline and include a defined number of revisions.
• Exclusivity — Limited exclusivity can justify higher fees. If you don’t need exclusivity, negotiate lower licensing costs but no guaranteed region blocks.
• Fees and royalties — Expect either an upfront flat fee, a royalty on ticket or merch sales, or both. Negotiate a hybrid model to share risk.
• Insurance and indemnity — IP owners will require insurance and typical indemnity clauses. Prepare general liability and product liability if selling food-related merch; see the Operational Playbook for permit and insurance checklists.
• Moral clauses — IP owners may place restrictions on how characters are used. Clarify boundaries early to avoid costly redesigns.

Operational playbook: launch checklist & timeline

Plan a 10–12 week rollout for a polished pop-up. Here’s a condensed schedule and action items.

Weeks 10–8: Planning & IP alignment

• Secure license (term, scope, merch rights, approvals).
• Define menu concept & price tiers. Produce 3–5 test recipes for approvals.

Weeks 7–5: Design & build

• Set menu engineering targets: plate cost targets (20–35% food cost for experiential menus).
• Design set, props, signage; order merch samples.

Weeks 4–2: Staff training & soft-launch

• Train front-of-house on lore, dish storytelling and upsell scripts.
• Run invitation-only rehearsals for family and IP stakeholders; collect feedback.

Week 1: Marketing & ticketing

• Open pre-sales in tiers. Use social proof (artist art, signed copies) to push VIP packages. If you need a quick ticketing or restaurant-picker page, see this No-Code Micro-App + One-Page Site Tutorial.
• Deploy email automation: confirmation, lore primer, menu preview, and reminders.

Opening night and beyond

• Capture data: ask guests to opt into a mailing list and track merch conversion rates (see Small Business CRM + Maps for an ROI checklist).
• Run short-run promotions: weekday discount nights, repeat-visitor incentives. Voucher design and scarcity tactics are covered in Micro‑Event Economics.

Marketing & promotion strategies (2026 trends)

Leverage the trends shaping experiential dining in 2026:

• AR overlays: Use simple AR menus so guests can scan a dish and see a short animated panel from the graphic novel. For image handling and perceptual layers, see Perceptual AI & Image Storage. This increases dwell time and social shares.
• Creator collaborations: Partner with illustrators and podcasters attached to the IP for pop-up events and live signings — practical tips in the Local Photoshoots, Live Drops, and Pop‑Up Sampling guide.
• Festival tie-ins: Leverage local festivals and nightlife promoters (see Marc Cuban’s investments in themed experiences) to create weekend activations that drive scale — a catalog of micro-pop-up listings is available in Directory Momentum 2026.
• Limited-time scarcity: Announce finite runs and numbered merch to pressure early purchases.
• AI personalization (careful): Use AI to tailor email subject lines and ad creative, but keep menu personalization human-led to preserve authenticity.

Financial expectations & KPIs

Set realistic revenue goals. For a 6-week pop-up in an A-market with 60 covers/night and a $45 average ticket, you could project:

• Total covers: 25,200 (420 covers/week × 6 weeks)
• Food & beverage revenue: $1.13M (25,200 × $45)
• Merch uplift: 10–20% of guests buy merch — $60–120k additional

Adjust for your market size. Track these KPIs: cover rate, merch attach rate, average ticket, cancelation rate, repeat bookings and social engagement. For forecasting and cash management see Toolkit: Forecasting & Cash‑Flow Tools.

Common pitfalls and how to avoid them

• Poor storytelling: If the menu doesn’t reference the IP meaningfully, fans will disengage. Remedy: include lore snippets and sensory callbacks.
• Overcomplicated dishes: Dishes that can’t be reproduced at scale kill margins. Remedy: test for speed and plate cost early.
• Licensing headaches: Vague approvals slow launch. Remedy: require a Marketing & Creative SLA (service level agreement) in the contract.
• Neglecting safety & compliance: Selling food-related merch (spices, preserves) requires packaging and labeling compliance. Remedy: consult local food safety guidelines and product liability counsel — and consider serverless edge approaches to food‑label compliance for automated label generation and traceability.

Final checklist before you open

• Signed license with clear scope and merch terms
• Menu tested at service speed with cost controls
• Staff trained on story beats, upsells and allergen handling
• Merch inventory and POS configured for bundles
• AR or digital assets live and QA'd for mobile

Why this matters in 2026

Consumers in 2026 crave multi-sensory outings that can’t be replicated at home. The Orangery’s WME partnership shows that agencies and IP owners are actively seeking hospitality partners to expand their fan economies. When executed well, a themed pop-up becomes more than a dinner — it’s an extension of a narrative universe, a merchandising hub, and a marketing engine for both the IP and the restaurant.

Actionable takeaways

• Start with a short narrative arc and make each dish a scene.
• Secure clear licensing terms early — especially for merch.
• Price by experience and create tiered packages.
• Use AR and creator partnerships to increase shareability and attendance.
• Measure merch attach, average ticket and repeat booking to evaluate success.

Ready to build your pop-up?

Bring an IP to the table with clarity: a crisp menu map, a merchandising plan, and a licensing checklist. Whether you’re inspired by The Orangery’s transmedia success or adapting a local graphic novel, the framework above will help you convert fandom into sustainable revenue and memorable meals.

Want a customizable pop-up menu template and licensing checklist? Download our ready-to-use pack or contact our team at menus.top for a tailored consultation — we’ve helped operators convert narrative worlds into profitable dining experiences across Europe and North America.

Related Reading

• Micro‑Events to Micro‑Markets: a 2026 growth playbook
• Compact merch & promo ideas for limited runs
• Perceptual AI & image storage for AR menus
• Micro‑Event Economics: voucher design that sells out
• Building Trust in AI-driven Delivery ETAs: Data Governance Best Practices
• Smart Lighting on a Budget: Using RGB Lamps to Set Your Pizzeria's Vibe
• Small-Event Audio: Best Bluetooth Speakers for Intimate Modest Fashion Shows
• Buying From AliExpress: Warranty, Returns and Safety Tips for 3D Printers Bought by UK Gamers
• From Cocktails to Cleansers: How Artisanal Ingredient Sourcing Inspires Indie Skincare